The game leans into a "mad scientist" or sci-fi vibe rather than purely paranormal horror. Critics argue the jumpscares are predictable and the environment lacks a truly unsettling atmosphere.
The voice acting is often described as "amateurish" or "flat," and the character models are frequently mocked for their simplistic, clay-like appearance. Community Consensus Garten of Banban 2
The puzzles are frequently criticized for being tedious or unintuitive. Some sections, like the "Banbaleena classroom," are particularly polarizing, with some finding them unique and others calling them a "slog". The game leans into a "mad scientist" or
“Garten Of Ban Ban has this weird grasp on me now, like it's not good but it's not bad, it's just kinda there and has a pull on me somehow.” Reddit · r/gartenofbanban · 3 years ago like the "Banbaleena classroom