Start the audio when they add the most questionable ingredient. The "Gaming Fail"
Text overlay: "When she says she only dates guys who are 6'5 but she's 4'11." oh_my_god_bro_hell_nah_meme
Use a "zoom-in" effect on the character’s face or the mistake as the audio reaches the "Hell Nah" part. Quick Script for a Short/Reel Start the audio when they add the most