Nathan enlists Lucas’s help to surprise Haley with a romantic gesture.

Brooke finds herself in a compromising situation after reading a letter from Lucas. Meanwhile, Rachel attempts to make amends and repair her relationship with Mouth.

When It Isn't Like It Should Be | One Tree Hill Wiki | Fandom

Peyton receives a visit from Pete Wentz (playing himself) of Fall Out Boy, which the rest of the group initially finds hard to believe.

"" is the 18th episode of the third season of One Tree Hill . It originally aired on April 5, 2006. Episode Summary