: Eleanor Guthrie proposes a massive exchange: she will surrender the British fort and troops in Nassau in exchange for the buried Urca de Lima treasure and safe passage for herself and her people.
: A standout scene involves Silver questioning Flint about whether he would trade the war for the life of Thomas Hamilton, forcing both to confront their deepest losses.
Notes that "everyone in this show has lost" and questions if anyone can truly win at this point. [S4E4] XXXII.
: Reviewers from Roar Cat Reads and Den of Geek highlight the episode's focus on the futility of vengeance. This is exemplified by the brutal slave revolt on the plantations and Anne Bonny's harrowing, tenacious fight to the death. Critical Consensus Rating / Verdict Commentary Den of Geek 4 out of 5 stars
: The episode begins to tear their "thick as thieves" partnership apart. Billy Bones successfully exploits Silver's vulnerabilities—specifically his feelings for Madi—while Flint makes an executive decision to strike a deal with Eleanor Guthrie, largely against Silver's wishes. : Eleanor Guthrie proposes a massive exchange: she
: Eleanor Guthrie is noted for regaining her "authority, experience, and know-how," behaving as a commander born for the role.
Describes the episode as "complicated" and "poignant," moving pieces effectively toward the series finale. : Reviewers from Roar Cat Reads and Den
Highlights the tension when Flint and Silver realize they are no longer on the same page regarding Nassau's future.